If you’re relocating or planning to move, renting out your current home might seem like a practical solution. It can create an additional income stream and help you build long-term equity. But before making that decision, it’s worth taking a step back. Turning your primary residence into a rental comes with financial, emotional, and logistical considerations that can affect your outcome for years to come.
Here are six key questions to help you think through the process.
1. Would You Buy This Home as a Rental?
The first question to ask is simple: if you didn’t already own this home, would you buy it as a rental property?
Start by looking at factors that influence how appealing your home is to renters. The floor plan is often a deciding factor. A layout with awkward room connections or narrow stairways can be a dealbreaker for renters trying to fit furniture or create a comfortable flow.
Condition and curb appeal also matter. Renters notice first impressions, the quality of the neighbourhood, the upkeep of nearby yards, and the overall condition of the home. Even small details like odors, paint, and lawn maintenance can influence whether someone decides to rent.
Size is another consideration. A large backyard may sound attractive, but most renters see extra yard space as additional upkeep.
Good rental properties tend to balance functionality, comfort, and maintenance. These ideas often align with the practical tips shared in 5 Habits Shared by Landlords, where consistency and attention to detail help attract and retain great tenants.
2. How Much Will You Actually Profit Each Month?
When evaluating potential income, it’s easy to focus on cash flow, but the real picture is broader. What matters is net profit, which factors in all income, expenses, and long-term growth.
The first year may not look especially profitable. You’ll likely spend extra on painting, cleaning, and upgrades to attract reliable renters. Vacancy periods can also temporarily reduce income.
Over time, however, rental properties generate wealth through multiple channels, appreciation, principal paydown, tax benefits, and cash flow. Even a break-even first year can be worthwhile when long-term appreciation and mortgage reduction are considered.
Be sure to set aside funds for repairs. Over a ten-year period, maintenance typically averages around 12% of gross rent. That number may seem high, but it includes big-ticket items like roofs, water heaters, and furnaces.
Understanding how these variables influence profitability aligns with broader insights about property management costs and the true expenses of maintaining an investment home.
3. Can You Emotionally Detach?
It’s not always easy to separate emotion from investment. When you’ve lived in a home for years, it carries memories and meaning. Renting it out means accepting that others will live differently.
Tenants may decorate in ways you wouldn’t. They may be less meticulous about the yard or create wear and tear that feels personal. Preparing for that shift is part of being a landlord.
Viewing your property as a business helps keep expectations realistic. Think in terms of income, expenses, and customer satisfaction rather than personal preference. It’s about maintaining a valuable asset, not preserving a specific way of living.
4. What Are Your Long-Term Plans?
Your timeline shapes your decision. If you plan to return to the home in a few years, converting it into a rental can serve as a short-term solution. Even if the floor plan or neighborhood isn’t ideal, the arrangement may work while you’re away.
If you don’t plan to move back, selling could make more sense. For example, one high-value property might be exchanged for two smaller rentals that provide more consistent income and less vacancy risk.
Investors also look at interest rates when deciding whether to hold or sell. A low mortgage rate can offset less-than-perfect rental conditions, allowing a property to remain profitable even with modest rent.
The process of managing that balance often mirrors what’s discussed in selecting the right property manager, where experience and clear long-term goals play a key role.
5. What Tax Benefits Come With a Rental Property?
Rental ownership offers several tax advantages that can make a significant difference over time.
Depreciation allows you to reduce taxable income without spending cash. A 1031 Exchange can defer capital gains when you sell and reinvest in another property. And in terms of estate planning, the “stepped-up basis” rule means heirs can inherit the property’s current market value rather than its original purchase price, reducing potential capital gains taxes.
Each of these benefits contributes to the long-term financial appeal of holding real estate.
6. What Are the Broader Benefits of Owning Rental Property?
Cash flow is often the most visible benefit, but it’s usually the smallest one over time. The true value comes from a combination of appreciation, principal paydown, tax advantages, and cash reserves.
Appreciation tends to be the largest contributor to long-term wealth, while principal paydown and depreciation strengthen financial stability year after year. The combination of these factors helps build lasting equity and financial flexibility, whether for retirement or future investments.
If you ever decide to rent a room or share space within your property, many of the same considerations apply as those outlined in Picking a Good Roommate, where compatibility, clear expectations, and planning make all the difference.
Final Thoughts
Turning your home into a rental can be a rewarding decision when approached with preparation and a business mindset. Taking time to assess these six questions will help set realistic expectations and ensure your property contributes to your long-term financial goals.
For more information about property management in your area, visit Real Property Management Viking.
We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.
